It will cleanse your soul and make you a better person." The Contenders Its really difficult to define which one is best because both calibers have their own advantages. For sights, I installed the new EOTech XPS3 HWS on each one. Up first would be an interior wall façade. Both rounds easily passed through the basic wallboard material and then through the thicker wall and double 2×4 target. Also, 9mm FMJ training ammunition costs about half the price of .223 FMJ training ammunition. 22lr Ammo and 9mm ammo is one of the most commonly used ammunition in the USA. As for our initial conversation, was the 9mm carbine less likely to “over-penetrate” than the .223?

I think I read on this site about a 9mm that ricocheted off a diller at 40 or 50 yards. That makes the 9mm at 1150 fsp at a 100y with a TKO of 7 and a Hornaday hits of 201. Choosing right ammunition for self defence and hunting is really important for gun owners. They also suit smaller hands and have less recoil than more powerful models like a 40 caliber, or 45 caliber handgun. The dual “circle and dot” reticle was used. So, 9mm is the right option as compare to 22lr for self defence. Which round is best for you and your shooting or defense needs? Both friends and long time shooters agree the 9mm did better than they thought it would. The ammunition for this review would be that specifically designed from personal protection. It isn't suitable for use against men that may be about the same size as a deer. More experienced shooters, or shooters focused on self-defense would be better served with a 9mm. Acts 10:13. Metalform 32-round stick magazines fed the 9mm carbine.

Carbines or rifles are more imposing than handguns and send a stronger message. When it strikes an animal it will likely stay in the animal and not send a random round through the woods. Step two was to fire the .223 cartridge from Hornady.

But paper is paper and I have not shot any game with the 9mm to judge. That cinched it for me. .22 or a 9mm can both be the right option for beginners or for an inexperienced shooter. As the standard round for the US Military and NATO, it is much larger and powerful than the 22lr. Choosing right ammunition for self defence and hunting is really important for gun owners. That said then you must feed it the right kind of bullet to get the most out of that speed depending on the size of the target. Capturing the fired bullets would be accomplished through the construction of a bullet trap of sorts. MY load is 124 grain at 1450 they were shooting 50 grain Hornaday at 3335 from there web sight. This barrier was built using two layers of half-inch sheet rock and a single layer of quarter-inch plywood. 22lr or 9mm? Take your absolute best 9mm round and put it up against one of my favorite 5.56 rounds, the Mk 262. Hornady has been offering their TAP (Tactical Application Police) defensive line for some time now and it has seen success in real-world encounters. 22 LR is often a much cheaper option as compare to 9mm ammo. It would seem that the purpose-designed .223 Remington load would be less likely to pass through an attacker and continue on through an interior wall than the 9mm fired from the same platform. The difference in accuracy and terminal energy transfer will be astounding. We have one of the largest stocking inventory selection of the best rimfire, handgun, and rifle ammunition. Every item listed in stock on our website is on hand at our warehouse. 8), "...And there came a voice to him, Rise, Peter; kill, and eat." A hit by the 9mm would be bad. To the casual reader this might seem like a very reasonable compromise. ARs/AKs/SKS/Class III Tactical/Self Defense,, Blackpowder Mortar & Cannon by Seacoast Artillery, Hand Loading Rifles & Handguns by Diamond K Brass, VerticalScope Inc., 111 Peter, Suite 901, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. The resulting groups were predictably tight. We would stay away from if it was our first time on the shooting range. 22lr Ammo and 9mm ammo is one of the most commonly used ammunition in the USA. What was most impressive was the fact that the .223 round deposited 100 percent of its energy into 8 inches of wax media. When fired from my CMMG rifle, this loaded averaged 2,855 FPS (feet per second) over a Shooting Chrony F1 chronograph. When we are talking about self defence, we need to be able to shoot the round accurately and reliably. Specialized in bulk ammo quantity for 22lr, 9mm, 223 and more popular cartridges. I have read the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, and Cookie Policy, and I hereby agree to those terms. Keeping the 223 in a straight line after impact is hard. One model chambers the 5.56mm/.223 Remington round and the other the 9x19mm round. However, on the other side, the results were a bit more spectacular. A side by side comparison of the 5.7x28 vs. 9mm calibers. .40 S&W modern hollow-point ammunition as well as .223 rounds from an M4. The XPS3 uses only one CR123 Lithium battery and is more compact than older models. It's quiet and has very low recoil so it's comfortable to shoot. .223 will go through pistol caliber vests, 9mm wont. As for our initial conversation, was the 9mm carbine less likely to “over-penetrate” than the .223? Taking a moment to closely examine the bullet box, I pried apart the layers of wax media and found that the .223 TAP round had penetrated just shy of 8 inches. This would represent a standard interior wall construction, minus 2×4 studs. Mannyrock pretty well summed it up, in my opinion. Wal-Mart where the discriminating white trash shop. The .22 is good for small game about the size of a squirrel to that of a possum or raccoon. The .223 is a better choice for inflicting damage and death at 100 yards. The free-floating 5.56mm barrel has 1 in 7 right hand twist rifling.

If this bullet looks familiar it is because the copper-colored projectile is the heart of Winchester’s Ranger LE ammunition line. Ok spent some time with friends today shooting milk jugs filled with water at 50y 9mm carbine hand load 124 Remington JHP at 1457 5 jugs stopped in 6th. Psalm 37, verse 4. Before we completely discount the 9mm carbine, it does have some positive attributes. Over my chronograph, this load averaged 1,140 FPS from the 16-inch barrel. While not the perfect medium, Clear Ballistics synthetic gelatin can give us a relative idea of how ammo will perform. If you own a 9mm handgun commonality of ammunition is a plus. Same load again 4 jugs again no bullet again on 3rd try 4 jugs no bullet different shooter.

The bottom line is that a pistol cartridge, even when fired from a carbine, is still going to perform like a pistol cartridge. I needed to construct some realistic test barriers and bullet-capturing devices. Both models are accurate and powerful. "Go afield with a good attitude, with respect for the wildlife that you hunt and for the forest and fields in which you walk. The carbine platform has the advantage of being easier to control, aim, and hit your target with. Will try a different bullet next time. Difference between 9mm and 22 lr is quite wide. Next AR 223 Factory load Hornady 55 grain SP at 2868 FPS 3 jugs bullet not found think it went out the side of 3RD jug. I was privy to a conversation at a local gun shop where a man was pondering the purchase of a long gun for home protection. The 9mm lower was a dedicated receiver, not a plugged or modified AR-type. © 2020 Outdoor Limited All Rights Reserved. The easy shooting 22 LR is excellent for new shooters and older people. We Report, You Decide ... the reason we care about it is because we’re looking to stop a threat.

After placing the wallboard material in front of the bullet trap, I took aim. A forum community dedicated to the great outdoors and hunting enthusiasts. On the front of the wallboard was an unimpressive .22 caliber hole. It had not deformed and looked almost good enough to be reloaded. A tight 1.17-inch three-shot cluster at 50 yards proved the carbine and ammo combination could be counted on. Which one is better?

Most folks assume that handgun rounds will not penetrate structures of a house as deeply as higher … Its really difficult to define which one is best because both calibers have their own advantages. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window), PWS MK111 Pro Pistol: An Affordable, Piston-Driven Pistol in .223 Wylde, SIG Custom Works Launches Limited Equinox Series P226, P229 Pistols, Timney Releases CZ Scorpion Trigger With Pull Weights Under 3 Pounds, Apex Tactical FN 509 Slide: 5-Inch Upgrade Includes RMR Optic Cut, 1791 Gunleather Optic-Ready Holsters Now Fit Glock G43x, G48 Pistols, CMC KRAGOS Glock Slide: Like Adding Another Gun to Your Armory, WATCH: Miami Mom Grabs Pistol, Defends Family From Armed Intruders, Vietnam War Veteran Cites War Experience, Holds Gun on Intruder, REPORT: Concealed Carriers Grow Nearly 20 Million During Trump Term, 5 Pro Tips to Shoot a Small Semi-Auto Pistol More Effectively, Accurately, WATCH: Master the Pistol Draw Stroke With Team SIG Sauer’s Max Michel, SCCY DVG-1: The 9mm Pistol That Puts 10+1 in a Sub-$300 Package. next 9mm carbine hand load 147 grain FMJ at 1324 hot load over book 7 jugs stopped in backstop where you could see the bullet. 9mm is louder, has more recoil, and is more challenging to shoot. Into the bullet box I place thick squares of waxy ballistic media. Featured herein would be their 60-grain TAP load chambered in .223 Remington. I had a 9mm got rid of it just bought a .223 AR 15 and am very disappointed in it! At that depth I discovered several bullet fragments. Based upon our range experiments, I believe we can see how this is not necessarily the case at all. To be honest both the 9mm and the .223 are under powered and over rated cartridges! So choose ammunition according your need. Consider that the torso on most human attackers will be anywhere from 10 to 15 inches, depending on the angle and human variables. Based upon our range experiments, I believe we can see how this is not necessarily the case at all. my 9mm carbines are a hoot to shoot and CHEAP to feed with my cast lead bullets. A hole nearly three 3 inches across and as deep was left in the wax media. The real edge pistol caliber carbines have is easy handling and less blast if fired indoors for HD. 22lr ammo is really good option for hunting as compare to 9mm ammo.